Karen's Review of
Circle of Stones
by Anna Lee Waldo

Columbus discovered the New World in 1492, right? Not according to Welsh Legend. There is some basis to the claim that Madoc, son of Owain, Prince of Gwynedd, discovered North America in 1170, over 300 years before Columbus.

Circle of Stones is the first in a series of historical fiction books that deal with Madoc, his claim of discovering N.A. and succeeding generations. Circle of Stones starts with one of Owain of Gwynnedd's mistresses, Brenda, who is to conceive Madoc under the brilliant Northern Lights, fulfilling a druidic prophecy. The story follows the life of Brenda till shortly after the death of Owain.

The late 1100's was a period of conflict in Wales and all of the British Isles. The "Old Religionists" (Druids) were trying to maintain their way of life, while the "New Religionists" (Christians) were on the ascendancy. The Welsh also had to contend with England's King Henry and his desire to control Wales, while many of the sons of Owain were in a constant power struggle to be the next ruler of Gwynedd.

Anna Lee Waldo has a tendancy in her writing to skip large periods of time without clearly letting her readers know how much time has elapsed. She has also made Brenda's character appear too strong and noble in character in contrast to Owain's weak and conniving wives. Otherwise, this story is well-written and very interesting. I learned a lot about the social fabric of Wales in the late 12th century, and especially about the druidic communities of that time. I sincerely hope that it won't take Waldo long to continue her story of Madoc and his trek to the New World.


Buy Circle of Stones by Anna Lee Waldo today!

Back Home or Back to Historical Fiction

Written June 30, 1999

Text Copyright©1999