1 JACOB PENCE was born about 1710 probably in Germany; married Catherine _____ [also called Mary Catherine in some records] about 1737; died near Cub Run, Augusta (now Rockingham) Co VA before 27 Feb 1750/51 when his brother Valentine Pence gave bond as executor of his will, dated 20 Dec 1750. Will mentions his sons Jacob and George, each to have a third with their mother, unnamed, "when they come of age." Jacob, George, John and William Pence, and Christian Persinger (husband of Jacob's daughter Barbara), received settlement in 1768 from Peter Miller, who was executor of Valentine Pence's will. Jacob Pence's widow remarried to Jacob Persinger, date not known, and they went to Botetourt Co VA. Children:

11 JACOB PENCE was no doubt the John Jacob Bentz, son of Jacob Bentz, whose birth on 3 Feb 1739 (baptized 15 Apr 1739, sponsors: Peter Rousch and wife) was recorded in the personal journal of the Rev. John Casper Stoever as the son of Jacob Bentz, Swatara (the DAR record that he was born 20 Dec 1730 is in error as he was only just coming of age about 1762); died - Feb 1800 [1806 deed record] at Cub Run, Rockingham Co VA; married Catherine Persinger about - Feb 1763 Augusta Co (after her father and his stepfather Jacob Persinger brought suit for breach of promise). Children:

1154 MOSES PENCE was born 15 Oct 1807 in Allegheny County, Virginia (was Bath County or Botetourt County then); died 13 Apr 1873 in Monroe County, West Virginia; married Delilah Smith in 1834 in Monroe County (she was born 25 Jan 1812, died 28 May 1872, buried in Pence Cemetery, Union, Monroe County). Children:

1154A HENRY WILSON PENCE was born 11 Oct 1857 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 1918 or 1919 in Monroe County; married Mary Edgar Burdette 1 Jul 1875 in Monroe County (she was born about 1855). Children:

1154A1 LUCY B. PENCE was born 12 May 1876 in Monroe County, West Virginia (Apr in birth index); died 16 Apr 1878 in Monroe County (1 Apr in death index).

1154A2 ERNEST LEE PENCE was born 19 May 1877 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 4 Feb 1904, buried in Mount Herman Baptist Church Cemetery, Sarton, Monroe County; married Bertha Mae Weikle 17 Aug 1898 in Monroe County (she was born in 1880).

1154A3 DELONY (DELONA) ELVERTON PENCE was born 12 Aug 1878 in Rock Camp, Monroe County, West Virginia; died 2 Jan 1933 in Monroe County, buried in Lillydale, Monroe County, West Virginia; married (Irene) Salome Irene Weikle in 1900 in Monroe County (she was born in 1875).

1154A4 ANDREW PRESTON PENCE was born 2 Dec 1881 in Monroe County, West Virginia (1880 on birth record); died 15 Dec 1955 in Monroe County, buried in the United Methodist Church Cemetery at Sarton, Monroe County; married (Eliza) Lula Baker 16 Feb 1904 in Monroe County (she born 23 Mar 1886, died 19 Dec 1960, buried United Methodist Church Cemetery).

1154A5 BEULAH BROWN PENCE was born 16 Sep 1883 in Monroe County, West Virginia; married Henry Frederick Baker 17 Aug 1898 in Monroe County.

1154A6 CLARENCE B. PENCE was born 3 Jan 1885 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 9 or 12 May 1906 in Monroe County.

1154A7 MARY MILLER PENCE was born 9 Apr 1889 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 1963; married Charles Denny Thompson in 1908 in Monroe County.

1154A8 EDGAR PENDLETON PENCE (PRESTON?) was born 25 Sep 1894 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 5 May 1963; married Hallie Ava Pitzer 24 April 1916 in Monroe County (she was born 27 May 1893, died - Jun 1977 possibly at Union, Monroe County, her addresss of record with the Social Security Administration, the daughter of Robert H. Pitzer and Agnes R. Canterberry).

1154A9 MARY BELLE PENCE was born about 1896 in Monroe County, West Virginia.

1156 DAVID PENCE was born 11 Mar 1810 in Virginia; died 28 Apr 1894, age 89 years, 18 days (?), buried Pence Cemetery, Union, Monroe County, West Virginia; married Mary F. Rankin Clark 16 Apr 1835 in Monroe County (she was born - May 1817, died 21 Oct 1877, age 61 years, 5 months and 16 days, buried Pence Cemetery, the daughter of John C. Clark and Mary Elizabeth Johnson). Children:

11561 WILLIAM H. PENCE was born 4 May 1836 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 2 Dec 1878; married Mrs Margaret (_____) Smith 28 Apr 1874 in Monroe County, West Virginia.

11562 MARGARET E. PENCE was born 11 May 1838 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 13 Aug 1913; married John W. (H.?) Canterberry 1859 in Monroe County.

11563 GEORGE WASHINGTON PENCE was born 18 Oct 1840 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 13 Oct 1909, buried in Pence Cemetery, Union, Monroe County, (G. P. Pence on stone); married Alwilda Susan (Alice) Clark about 1881 (she was born in 1854, died in 1932, buried Pence Cemetery).

11564 (VIRGINIA) FRANCES PENCE was born 27 Aug 1843 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 11 Apr 1916; married James Mat Jones in 1866 in Monroe County (he was born in 1840, died in 1917).

11565 AUGUSTUS A. PENCE was born 9 Feb 1846 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 18 Jun 1902, buried in Mount Hedding Methodist Church Cemetery, Union, Monroe County; married Margaret A. McNeer in 1880 in Monroe County (she was born in 1848, died in 1914, buried in Mount Hedding Methodist Church Cemetery).

11566 ELIZABETH C. PENCE was born 23 Aug 1848 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 15 Aug 1907; married (Erastus) Preston Lowe in 1869 in Monroe County (he was born 21 Sep 1842 in Monroe Count, the son of Joshua Lowe and Lucilla Duncan); Elizabeth was living with her father and brothers with two children in 1880; they had children who are buried in the cemetery at Enid, Garfield County, Oklahoma.

11567 JOHN W. PENCE was born 14 Jul 1851 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 6 Nov 1917; unmarried in 1880 in Monroe County, West Virginia.

11568 (CAROLINE) ELLEN PENCE was born 23 Mar 1854 in Monroe County, West Virginia; died 2 Jan 1929, buried in Pence Cemetery, Union, Monroe County; married John E. Murdock in 1883 in Monroe County (he was born in 1861, died in 1952, buried in Pence Cemetery).

11569 HUGH P. PENCE was born 10 Nov 1860 Monroe County, West Virginia; died 19 Sep 1916; married Virginia A. Harvey in 1894 Monroe County.

117 HENRY PENCE was born about 1775 in Augusta County, Virginia; apparently died in 1836 in Rockingham County, Virginia (but see also No. 23 and 124); married Margaret (Rebecca) Dundore 10 Nov 1800 Rockingham County. Children (the last four went to Henry County, Indiana, by 1836):

1173 CHRISTIAN PENCE was born 23 Sep 1805 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 1 May 1875 in Henry County, Indiana, age 69 years, 7 months and 3 days, buried in Miller's United Brethren Church Cemetery, Fall Creek Twp, Henry County; married Francis Fisher 20 May 1828 Rockingham County (she was born in 1810, died 14 Sep 1886, age 76 yrs, 7 months and 24 days, buried with husband; they migrated to Henry County, 1829. Children:

11732 ABRAHAM WASHINGTON PENCE was born 6 Feb 1831 in Henry County, Indiana; died 11 Aug 1901 in Delaware County, Indiana, buried Prairie Grove Cemetery, Washington Twp, Delaware County; married (Mary) Elizabeth Moffett 23 Mar 1854 in Henry County (she died 16 Mar 1869, age 34 years, 10 months and 11 days, buried with her husband, the daughter of Lambert and Maria Moffett). Children:

117321 (CHRISTIAN) LAMBERT PENCE was born 15 May 1855 in Indiana; married (1) Mary J. Clark 24 Jul 1887, (2) Nannie A. Jones 18 Dec 1907, (3) Minerva Lane 29 Aug 1920, all in Delaware County, Indiana; he was living with Walter R. Pence and family (No. 117345) in 1920.

117322 SAMUEL P. PENCE was born - May 1857 in Indiana; married Mary J. Ice 11 Jul 1885 in Madison County, Indiana; living Eagle Twp, Vermillion County, Indiana, in 1900.

117323 AMANDA JANE PENCE was born in 1858 (age 1 in 1860 census); married Henry Hazelbaker 16 Mar 1888 in Delaware County, Indiana.

117324 FRANCES MARIA PENCE was born in 1860; died 12 Sep 1862, age 1 year, 9 months and 10 days, buried Prairie Grove Cemetery, Washington Twp, Delaware County, Indiana, with parents.

117325 _____ PENCE, unnamed infant daughter, apparently a twin to the above, died 7 Feb 1860, age three days, buried with parents.

117328 SUSAN LENA LEOTA PENCE was born in 1865 in Indiana; probably the Leni Pence who married Joseph M. Robinson 6 Mar 1888 in Delaware County, Indiana.

117327 (ALFRED) (JAMES) LARKIN PENCE was born 2 Mar 1867 in Delaware County, Indiana; married Katie B. Swain 24 Dec 1902 in Delaware County; he was a boarder with Henry Parton, Washington Twp, Delaware County, in 1900; he was called Larkin A. on his marriage record.

11C CHARLES PERSINGER PENCE was born 21 Oct 1786 Rockingham Co VA; died 27 Aug 1861 in Clinton Co IN; married (1) Mary Dundore 10 Dec 1808 in Rockingham Co, (2) Anna (Roof) Hoffman 3 Apr 1816 in Shenandoah Co VA (she married (1) Christian Hoffman 7 Oct 1812 in Shenamdoah Co), (3) Sarah (Pence) Kyger 16 Jan 1840 (license dated 11 Jan) in Delaware Co IN (see 1252 below), Children, first three by first wife, last by third wife:

11C1 CYRUS PERSINGER PENCE was born 15 Nov 1809 in Rockingham Co VA, doubtless the Carl Persina with parents Carl (Charles) Pence and Maria Dundore who was baptized at Peaked Mountain Church in Rockingham Co on 10 Jun 1810; died 29 Jan 1885 in Henry Co IN; married (1) Elizabeth Littell 2 Feb 1835 in Shenandoah Co VA, (2) Catherine Kyger 23 Sep 1849 in Clinton Co IN (she was born 8 Jun 1827 in Rockingham Co, died 25 May 1909 in IN, daughter of George Kyger and Sarah Pence Kyger [see 1252]); to Clinton Co 1836, Henry Co 1859. Children, first eight by first wife:

11C1F ALBERT ABNER PENCE was born 1 Feb 1864 in Henry County, Indiana; married Ola R. Murray 5 Aug 1897 in Henry County (she was born in 1871 in Indiana, the daughter of John C. and Mary Murray); they were in New Castle, Henry County, in 1900, 1910, 1920 and 1930. Children:

11C1F1 MARIAN PENCE was born 6 Mar 1896 in Henry County, Indiana; she was living with her parents in New Castle, Henry County, Indiana, in 1930 witht eh occupation of store clerk.

11C1F2 LEE TREES PENCE was born 1 Sep 1899 in Henry County, Indiana; died 31 Jan 1952 in Los Angeles County, California; married Frances C. Holtman in 1920 (she was born 27 Jul 1894 in Illinois, died 5 Oct 1963 in Santa Clara County, California), the dauther of Henry J. Holtman and Elizabeth Keck), they were living with her sister Louis M. and her husband Francis S. Hawks in Oakland, Alameda County, California, in 1920.

11C1F3 EUGENE RUNYON PENCE was born 4 Jul 1901 in Henry County, Indiana; died 25 Sep 1918 of influenza at Great Lakes Naval Training Station, Waukegan, Lake County, Illinois; he enlisted in the U.S. Navy 22 Jul 1918, assigned to Great Lakes Naval Training Staation as an apprentice seaman, promoted to seaman second class.

11C3 ABNER PENCE was born 12 Oct 1812 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 30 Oct 1890 in Clinton County, Indiana; married Sarah S. Taylor (also called Tille) 16 Jun 1840 in Clinton County. Children:

11C31 MARY CATHERINE PENCE was born 5 Apr 1841 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 24 May 1864 in Clinton County; married George Duckworth Blinn 20 Mar 1861 in Clinton County.

11C32 ANNA ELIZA PENCE was born 16 Apr 1843 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 28 Nov 1890 in Clinton County; married Joseph Silverthorn 11 Apr 1865 in Clinton County.

11C33 GEORGE WASHINGTON PENCE was born 14 Apr 1845 in Clinton County, Indiana; married Eliza Jane Terwiliger 5 Oct 1869 in Clinton County (she was born in 1852 in Indiana); they were in Oiwen County, Clinton County, in 1880.

11C34 (CHARLES) MARION PENCE was born 14 Apr 1845 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 22 Feb 1880 in Clinton County; married Elva Ann Ragle 10 Jun 1871 in Benton County, Indiana. 11C34 (CHARLES) MARION PENCE was born 14 Apr 1845 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 22 Feb 1880 in Clinton County; married Elva Ann Ragle 10 Jun 1871 in Benton County, Indiana.

11C35 JOHN ABNER PENCE was born 1 Feb 1848 in Clinton County, Indiana; married (1) Elizabeth Landis 31 Oct 1871 in Marion County, Indiana, (2) Sarah Ames (she was born 11 Apr 1852 in Perry County, Ohio, died 8 Sep 1918, the daughter of Jabish Gilead Ames and Elizabeth Jean Martin). There are four children listed for him and which wife was their mother is uncertain. However, Sarah Jane is shown as the mother of the last three according to an entry in the Ancestral File. Apparently this couple was separated by the time of the 1880 census. The two older daughters were found living in other households and the two boys and the parents could not be located in that census. Several records pertaining to the son David George indicate he was born in Independence, Jackson County, Missouri, but the familly was not there in 1880, nor is there any indication they ever lived there.

11C36 SARAH SAMANTHA PENCE was born 19 Jan 1850 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 28 Jul 1889 in Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania; married George Rhine 4 Mar 1868 Clinton County.

11C37 JAMES FRANKLIN PENCE was born 18 Jul 1852 in Clinton County, Indiana; married Mary Belle (Mollie) Hendrickson 21 Oct 1874 in Clinton County.

11C38 MELDORA CARMEL (DORA) PENCE was born 24 Aug 1854 Clinton County, Indiana; married Sanford Clinton Caldwell 21 Feb 1878 in Clinton County.

11C39 JUSTINA MAY BELLE (JESSIE) PENCE was born 23 May 1856 in Clinton County, Indiana; married William M. Simms 23 Apr 1879 in Clinton County (called Jessie M. on the marriage record).

11C3A DAVID HIRAM PENCE was born 5 Aug 1859 in Clinton County, Indiana; died 4 Mar 1880 in Clinton County; listed as D. HenryY, age 20, living with father in 1880, probably the same as David Hiram, making the death date above in error.

11C3B LULU BELLE PENCE was born 23 Oct 1861 in Clinton County, Indiana (but age 16 in 1880); married Joseph Edward Scroggy 13 Nov 1883 in Clinton County.

12 GEORGE PENCE was no doubt the John George Bentz, son of Jacob Bentz, Swatara, whose birth on 9 Apr 1743 (baptized 23 May 1743, spnosors: John George Kuntz and wife) was recordes in the personal journal of the Rev. John Casper Stoever (some say George was born at sea in 1737, but this appears impossible as neither he nor his older brother were of age when their father wrote his will in 1750); died 19 Dec 1816 (other dates given, including especially 1819) Sullivan Co TN; married (1) Sarah Perkey about 1764 (before 18 Aug 1764 when they were sponsors at a baptism) probably in Augusta Co VA, (2) Margaret Carpenter (alias Zimmerman) 12 Oct 1782 Rockingham Co VA (she was born about 1764 and died 13 Aug 1828 in Sullivan Co, the daughter of Geroge and Anna Carpenter); he was a captain in the Revolution; moved to Sullivan Co about 1812; may have been in Orange Co earlier. Children, first seven believed to be by first wife:

124 HENRY PENCE was born about 1770 in Augusta Co VA (80 years old in 1850 census); died in 1852 in Seneca Co OH (will 22 Mar, filed 14 Aug); married Margaret Albright 30 Apr 1805 in Rockingham Co VA (she possibly the one who is buried in Seneca Co, died 17 May 1840, age 53 yr, 6 mo, 9 da); to Perry Co OH, where he bought land in May 1817 and sold in Sep 1833; to Seneca Co, where he bought land in Jun 1834. Children, all except James from will:

1241 MALVINA PENCE was born about 1806 probably in VA; died before father's will; married Samuel McCormick 10 Apr 1827 in Perry Co OH.

1242 JAMES PENCE was born in 1810 in VA; died 1877; married Elizabeth Bowland - Sep 1836 Seneca Co OH (she born in 1817 in OH).

1243 MARY ANN (MARIA ANNA) PENCE was born 1 Oct 1811 in Rockingham Co VA (Peaked Mt record, daughter of Henry the son of George and Margaret); married _____ Geiton; possibly to Evart, Oseola Co MI.

1244 DAVID L. PENCE was born 17 Apr 1815 in VA (census records; descendants say Perry Co OH); died 4 Dec 1897 Seneca Co, 82 yr, 9 Mo, 24 da; married Eleanor Bowland 10 Feb 1842 Seneca Co (Ellen, Elnie, Eleanor in census records, she was born 1821 OH); living om Pleasant Twp, Seneca Co in 1880 with a granddaughter Carrie, age 3.

1245 JOHN PENCE was born in 1818 probably in OH; died 10 Feb 1907 in Potawattomie Co OK at the home of a daughter; married Sabina (Selina, Celina) R. Brokaw 10 Apr 1845 in Seneca Co OH; in Seneca Co in 1850 amd 1860; he likely was the John born - Jun 1817 in OH, with wife Celina and listed as father-in-law of Jesse Crawford, Woodville Twp, Sandusky Co OH in 1900 (census soundex).

1246 WILLIAM PENCE was born about 1820.

1247 SAMUEL PENCE was born in 1826; married Margaret Brokaw 16 Mar 1848 in Seneca Co OH.

12C JACOB PENCE was born 23 Apr 1793 in Rockingham Co VA; died 30 Jun 1873 in DeSoto, Dallas Co IA; married (Anna) Margaretta Roller 13 Nov 1817 in Sullivan Co TN (she died 18 Jan 1863 in Bartholomew Co IN, aged 63 yr, 9 mo and 4 da, buried Garland Brook Cemetery, Bartholomew Co, daughter of George Roller and Elizabeth (Betsey) Shipley]; to Bartholomew Co in 1828, first land purchase there in 1832; veteran of War of 1812. Children:

12C1 ELIZA ANNA PENCE was born 22 Aug 1818 in Sullivan Co TN; married Lewis Sims 9 Jul 1835 in Bartholomew Co IN.

12C2 DAVID PENCE was born 9 Apr 1820 in Sullivan Co TN; died 3 Oct 1868 in Bartholomew Co IN; married Nancy Hart 20 Feb 1845 in Bartholomew Co (daughter of Gideon Hart and Hettie Taylor).

12C3 GEORGE PENCE was born 9 Apr 1820 in Sullivan Co TN (twin); died 19 Mar 1847 in Monterey, Mexico; unmarried; Mexican War.

12C4 MARGARET PENCE was born 4 Dec 1822 in Sullivan Co TN; died 19 Aug 1869; married Western W. Jones 12 Feb. 1845 in Bartholomew Co IN (he was born in 1820 in Nelson Co KY, the son of William S. Jones and Celia Irwin).

12C5 SARAH PENCE was born 9 Nov 1827 in Sullivan Co TN; died age 86 in Independence, Jackson Co MO; married John Snyder 21 Apr 1851 in Bartholomew Co IN (he died in Louisville, Jefferson Co KY, the son of John Snyder and Malevia Yeager).

12C6 AMANDA KATHERINE PENCE was born 4 Nov 1830 in Bartholomew Co IN; married Julius J. Vanmeter 7 Aug 1851 in Bartholomew Co.

12E DAVID PENCE was born 6 Apr 1798 in Rockingham Co VA; died 17 Aug 1868 in Sullivan Co TN married Elizabeth Gott 1 Sep 1825 in Sullivan Co (she was born in TN). Children:

12E2 OLIVER PERRY PENCE was born 17 Mar 1828 in Sullivan Co TN; died 27 Jan 1897 in Polk Co IA; married Nancy Evalene Wilson 27 Jan 1856 in Sullivan Co (she was born in 1839 in TN); to Vigo Co IN in 1861, Polk Co in 1867 and living there in 1880, occupation, carpenter; Union soldier in Civil War, private in Co. C, 11th Indiana Inf. (see brother William G. Pence). Children:

12E21 ADA F. PENCE was born in 1857 in TN; called "music teacher" in 1880, living in Des Moines, Polk Co IA, unmarried in 1910.

12E22 CHARLES E. PENCE was born 18 Dec 1859 in TN; died 6 Aug 1941, buried Shaddox Cemetery, Nelson Co AR.

12E23 OSCAR S. PENCE was born in 1866 in IN; died before 1880.

12E24 NELLIE PENCE was born in 1869 in IA.

12E25 LUTIE PENCE was born in 1872 in Polk Co IA she has DAR record).

13 WILLIAM PENCE was born about 1745 possibly in Lancaster Co PA; died before 20 Jul 1819 (will filed in Rockingham Co); married Elizabeth _____ about 1774 (probably Price or Breis; she died 24 Aug 1835, age 72, in Preble Co OH). Children, from the parish register of St. Peter's Evangelical Lutheran Church, Shenandoah VA (church is in Rockingham Co):

14 JOHN PENCE was born about 1747 in Augusta Co VA; died 10 Jun 1826 in Shelby Co KY; married (1) Margaret Perkey about 1768 in VA, (2) Barbara Zimmerman (alias Carpenter) 10 Jan 1783 in Rockingham Co VA (she was born 29 Aug 1762 in Augusta Co, the daughter of George and Anna Carpenter); moved to Shelby Co about 1811 after having lived in Orange Co VA. Said to have had 11 children; which are by which wife is not known, although Conrad is said to be oldest by the second wife and perhaps John is the son of first wife. (Gen. W. P. Pence wrote, however, that John was by the second wife. Mary does not appear on Pence's list or other lists.) Children, probably not in correct order:

125 GEORGE PENCE was born about 1774 in Augusta County, Virginia; died before 1828 in Rockingham County, Virginia; married Christina Crowbarger 25 Sep 1798 in Rockingham County (she died 6 Feb 1861, age 83 years, 1 month, 21 days, buried in Kilmor Cemeter-West Yard, Clinton County, Indiana. Children:

1253 SAMUEL PENCE was born 6 May 1803 in Rockingham Co VA; died about 1841 in Rockingham Co; married Sarah (Sally) Kiblinger 29 Nov 1827 in Rockingham Co (she was born 2 Feb 1803, died 30 Mar 1885, buried Mill Creek Brethren Church Cemetery, Port Republic, Rockingham Co, daughter of Peter Kiblinger and Solema [Sarah] Carpenter). Children:

12531 DAVID B. PENCE was born 16 Oct 1828 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 16 Jul 1905 in Rockingham County, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic, Rockingham County; married Elizabeth Miller 1 Dec 1855 in Rockingham County (Sarah in 1860 census, she was born 1 Feb 1826, died 2 Sep 1905, buried Mill Creek Church of the Brthren Cemetery). Children:

125316 JOSEPH PENCE was born 2 Oct 1867 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 2 Feb 1957, buried in the Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic, Rockingham County; married Frances (Fannie) Elenore Showalter 6 Oct 1896 in Rockingham County (she was born 17 Oct 1869 in Virginia, died 13 Mar 1953, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, the daughter of Peter Harvey Showalter and Magdalene Heatwole); they lived in Bridgewater, Rockingham County, in 1920 and in Ashby District, Rockingham County, in 1930; not found in 1910 census. Children:

1253161 EFFIE MAGDALENE PENCE was born 28 Nov 1897 in Port Republic, Rockingham County, Virginia; died 28 Dec 1977, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic; married Charles Edward Miller 25 Jan 1939 (he was born 25 May 1884, died - Jun 1977, possibly in Bridgewater, Rockingham County, his Social Security Administration address, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery).

1253162 ETHEL ELIZABETH PENCE was born 8 Sep 1900 in Port Republic, Rockingham County, Virginia; died 12 Apr 1973, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic, Rockingham County, Virginia.

1253163 HAROLD PENCE was born 13 Mar 1902; died 19 Mar 1902, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic, Rockingham County, Virginia.

1253164 (JOSEPH) VIRGIL PENCE was born 2 Dec 1905 in Port Republic, Rockingham County, Virginia; died 7 May 1977, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, Port Republic; married Geneva Jane Whitmer 16 Jul 1944 (she was born 17 Jun 1913, died 7 May 1977, buried in Mill Creek Church of the Brethren Cemetery, the daughter of Oliver G. Whitmer and Bertha Glick).

1253165 (LYDIA) MARIE PENCE was born 1 May 1909 in Virginia; married Russell Webb Hartman 1 Jun 1932 (he was born 31 Oct 1908, the son of Walter Webb Hartman and Virginia (Francis) Wampler).

12533 WILLIAM PENCE was born 2 Sep 1831 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 26 Jan 1909 in St. Clair County, Missouri; married Cynthia Ann Givens 15 Sep 1860 in Lafayette County, Missouri (she died about 1882). Children:

125331 JOHN SAMUEL PENCE was born - Sep 1861 in Cooper County, Missouri; married Virginia Adalaide (Ada) Hendricks about 1890 (she was born 22 May 1867 in Missouri, died 16 May 1926 in St. Clair County, Missouri, the daugher of George W. Hendricks); he and his brothers Sylvester and Stonewall were with their grandmother in Rockingham County, Virginia, in 1870 and 1880; St Clair County in 1900 and his father with him; also in St. Clair in 1910; he and wife in Roscoe, St. Clair County, in 1920.

125332 (SYLVESTER) WILLIAM (VES) PENCE was born 6 Dec 1864 in St Clair County, Missouri; died - Jul 1955; married Anna Taylor 21 Aug 1890 in St Clair County (she was born in 1870 in Missouri); he lived with his grandmother Sarah Pence in Rockingham County in 1870 and 1880; he and his family were in St. Clair County in 1900, 1910 and 1920.

125333 ALBERT SYDNEY JOHNSTON PENCE was born 21 Sep 1867 in Cooper County, Missouri; died 3 Apr 1889; married Dora Belle Ryan 12 Aug 1888 in Tiffin, St. Clair County, Missouri (she was born 20 Jul 1872 in Pettis County, Missouri, the daughter of William Ryan and Mary R. Harris, she married two additional times).

125334 STONEWALL JACKSON PENCE was born in 1872 (census date) in Cooper County, Missouri; married Jenny Snyder 2 Mar 1886 in Cooper County.

125335 LON PENCE was born in 1876 in Cooper County, Missouri; died in infancy.

12536 FRANKLIN KOONTZ PENCE was born 19 Sep 1838 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died in 1919 in Jackson County, Missouri; married Elizabeth Francis Baxter 11 Oct 1866 in Rockingham County, (E. Flora in 1880 census of St. Clair County, Missouri); in Ft. Osage Twp, Jackson County, Missouri, in 1900 and in Jackson County in 1910. Children include:

125361 WILLIAM ELLIS S. PENCE was born 27 Nov 1867 in Virginia; died 9 Aug 1900 in Jackson County, Missouri; married Mary Josephine (Josie) Frazier 11 Mar 1890 (she was born 5 Jun 1872, died 5 Jan 1854).

125362 SARAH CATHERINE (SALLY KATE) PENCE was born in 1869 in Virginia.

125363 M. ALICE PENCE was born in 1871 in Virginia.

125364 MARGARET PENCE was born in 1874; apparently died young as not in 1880 census.

125365 (MAUD) MATILDA PENCE was born - May 1876 in Missouri.

125366 E. PRUDENCE PENCE was born in 1879 in Missouri.

125367 (RICHARD) CHARLES PENCE was born 3 Jul 1886 in Missouri; died - Aug 1963 in Missouri; married Katherine _____ about 1915 (she was born in 1889 in Ohio); they were in Jackson County, Missouri, in 1920 and in Osage Twp, Jackson County, in 1930.

125368 NOILA PENCE was born about 1901; married _____ Hostetler.

131 DAVID PENCE was born 25 Feb 1776 in Augusta Co VA; died between 1830 (census)) and 1833 (heirs sold land) in Preble Co OH; married Dorothy (Dolly) Hammer 2 Apr 1801 in Rockingham Co VA; to Preble Co OH where he purchased land 5 Sep 1821, the same day as his brother William (No. 133). Children:

1313 WILLIAM HARRY PENCE was born about 1805 in Rockingham Co VA; died age 97 according to family tradition, at Roann, Wabash Co IN, but his will was written 14 Feb 1884 and recorded 5 Jun 1893 in Wabash Co; married (1) Malinda Fudge 24 May 1831 in Preble Co OH (she was born 23 Aug 1811 in Lanier Twp, Preble Co), (2) Nancy Fudge 11 Jun 1850 Preble Co (she was born 16 Feb 1814, sister to first wife), (3) Margaret (Bryan) Gamble probably in Wabash Co. Children, last by second wife:

13131 (BENJAMIN) FRANKLIN PENCE was born 10 Mar 1832 at Eaton, Preble Co OH; died 3 Jul 1919 Huntsville, Randolph Co MS (at the home of a daughter), buried there; married Elizabeth Wilson 7 Dec 1854 in Preble Co; in Miami Co IN in 1880; living with Cyrus Pence in Preble Co in 1910.

13132 MARGARET LOUISA PENCE was born 28 Nov 1835 in Preble Co OH; died 10 Apr 1917 in Vista, St. Clair Co MO, buried Macedonia Cemetery there; married Finley Phineas Kincaid 20 Jan 1856 in Preble Co (he was born 30 Nov 1830 in Preble Co, died 16 Sep 1916 at Vista, buried Macedonia Cemetery, son of John Kinciad and Mary Moutrey).

13133 (THOMAS) BENTON (BENT) PENCE was born - Mar 1837 in Preble Co OH; married Amanda Yost 25 Dec 1860 in Preble Co; lived in Wabash Co IN in 1900.

13134 ELIZABETH C. PENCE was born 4 Feb 1842 in Preble Co OH; died in 1939; possibly she is the Elizabeth Caroline who married John Finley Hurt 5 Dec 1867 in Buchanan Co MO, since her brother was there by then.

13135 JACOB F. PENCE was born 7 Jul 1843 in Eaton, Preble Co OH; died 2 Apr 1914 at Dundee, Yamhill Co OR; married Mary Ellen Robertson 6 May 1874 in Dayton, Yamhill Co (she was born 18 Aug 1849 in Morrison, Whiteside Co IL, daughter of Adam Porteous Robertson and Elizabeth Crawford Hinsley).

132 ADAM PENCE was born 6 Jul 1779 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died about 1828 in Preble County, Ohio; married Elizabeth Petefish 25 Jun 1805 in Rockingham County (she was born 26 Feb 1788, the daughter of John Christian and Anna Maria Petefish (Beiderfisch); they went first to Warren County, Ohio, then to Preble County, where he purchased land 26 Sep 1821; Elizabeth Petefish Pence's mother was in Warren County in 1821 and in neighboring Butler County, Ohio, in 1825 (letters back to relatives in Rockingham County); in 1832 his daughter Sally Pence, of age, brought suit for partition of his land against Adam Bowsman, who had married Adam Pence's widow, Elizabeth (Elizabeth Pence married Adam Bowsman 7 Oct 1830 in Preble County); Adam had died some years before, intestate. Children (named in 1832 suit):

1323 THOMAS WINTERS PENCE was born 14 Dec 1817 in Ohio; died 27 Mar 1898 at York, York County, Nebraska, buried in Vernon Cemetery at York; married Elizabeth Vance 28 Apr 1842 in Randolph County, Indiana (she was born 22 Apr 1823 in Ohio, died 20 Jan 1892 in York County, buried Vernon Cemetery, apparently the daughter of George and Margaret Vance, who were living with her and her husband in the 1850 census of Randolph County [George Vance, age 74, and Margaret Vance, 66, both born in Pennsylvania]); according to a descendant, Thomas and his wife moved to Illinois (Tazewell County) about 1865, then to York County before 1880. Children, from census records and family information:

1323A GEORGE DOUGLAS PENCE was born - Feb 1861 in Indiana; buried in or around Whitesboro, Grayson County, Texas; married (1) Bernetta Silvester Brown about 1886 (she was born 25 Apr 1871 in Medora, Jackson County, Indiana, died 29 Jul 1951 in Kingman, Kingman County, Kansas, the daughter of Jack Brown), (2) Luella (Ella) Frances (Howard) Watkins about 1906 (she was born in 1882 in Texas); he was in Allen County, Kansas, in 1900 with his first wife and the first two children below and she was there in 1920 with her daughter Lulu Donoho and in 1930 with her daughter-in-law Katie (Parsons) Pence and Katie's three children; in 1920 he and his second wife were in Collinsville Twp, Grayson County, with the last four children below, as well as two Watkins stepchildren (Georgie, female age 17, and Mary, age 15) and George's brother Willis C. Pence. Children, first two by first wife, rest by second:

1323A1 LULA MAE PENCE was born 30 Aug 1887 in York, York County, Nebraska; died 12 Oct 1973 in Lyons, Rice County, Kansas, buried in Walnut Hill Cemetery in kingman, Kingman County, Kansas; married (1) Lawrence Donohoe in 1904 (he died in 1912), (2) Joseph C. Gutheridge 29 Mar 1920 (he died in 1961).

1323A2 ELTIE CLIFFORD PENCE was born 14 Jul 1889 in Elwood, Gosper County, Nebraska; died 3 Jan 1930; married Katherine (Katie) Parsons 21 Aug 1922 at Kingman, Kingman County, Kansas (she was born in 1903 in Kansas); she was the widowed head of household in Kingman, Kingman County, Kansas, in 1930; living with her was Bernetta Pence, mother-in-law (also listed as a widow, although she was divorced and her former husband was living in Texas with his second wife at the time).

1323A3 REUBEN JASPER PENCE was born in 1906 in Oklahoma; died 4 Mar 1968 in Cooke County, Texas.

1323A4 EVA PENCE was born in 1907 in Oklahoma.

1323A5 ZAY MANLEY PENCE was born 3 Jul 1910 in Oklahoma; died 15 Apr 1997 in Gainesville, Cooke County, Texas; married Dorothy Lorraine Riddle.

1323A6 GOLIE LEE PENCE was born 23 Sep 1912 in Texas; died 24 Jul 1983 in Grayson County, Texas, possibly Whitesboro, his address of record with the Social Security Administration; married Ora Belle Willis (she was born 3 May 1912, died 30 Jun 1984 in Grayson County, possibly in Whitesboro, her address of record with the SSA).

133 WILLIAM PENCE was born 18 May 1781 in Rockingham County, Virginia (tombstone; church record says he was born 27 May 1782 and was baptized 24 Apr 1782 [sic]); died 10 Jun 1849 in Preble County, Ohio, buried in Gettysburg Cemetery, Jefferson Twp, Preble County; married Christina Sellers 15 Sep 1801 in Rockingham County (she was born in Rockingham County, died 22 Jun 1849, buried in Gettysburg Cemetery, the daughter of Johannes Zeller [John Sellers] and Elizabeth Perkey). Children:

1332 JACOB PENCE was born 9 Jan 1805 in Rockingham Co VA; died 26 Jun 1876 in Pike Co IL; married Julia A. Bowsman 3 Oct 1828 in Preble Co OH (she was born 27 Dec 1806, died 18 Mar 1876 in Pike Co); to Pike County, Illinois; there in 1850 with the last four children listed below (since Susan is described as third child of this couple, there apparently were two older children):

13321 _____ PENCE unknown child.

13322 _____ PENCE unknown child.

13323 SUSAN PENCE was born in 1829 probably in OH (third child); died in 1913; married Joel Moomaw 18 Dec 1845 in Pike Co IL.

13324 ELIZABETH PENCE was born in 1831 in OH; probably she was the Susan who married John Simpson 6 Oct 1859 in Pike Co IL.

13325 CHRISTINA PENCE was born in 1833 in OH; possibly married Martin Sherer 11 Mar 1857 in Pike Co IL.

13326 (ANDREW) JACKSON PENCE was born - Jul 1835 in OH; married Elizabeth J. Orr 25 Dec 1856 in Pike Co IL (she was the daughter of William Orr and Anne Darrah); lived in Pike Co in 1880 and 1900. Morton).

13327 JEFFERSON WILLIAM PENCE was born in 1839 in IL; he possibly is the "C. J." Pence who died - Jan 1904, age 64, buried with other members of his family in Park Lawn Cemetery, Barry, Pike Co IL with a Civil War marker (from published inscriptions; he is not found after the 1900 census); married Evaline (Lena) Doran (she was born in 1845 in IL, daughter of _____ Doran and Jane Moore); in 1850 he is called William J., age 11, in his father's household, and in 1860 he was living on his own as Jefferson Pence; he surely is the one listed both as Jefferson Wm. Pence and William J. Pence who was a musician in Company I of the 28th Illinois Infantry in the Civil War; his residence is not given on the roster, but a great many of those in his company were from Barry in Pike Co and on 15 Jul 1903 William J. Pence, Pike Co, veteran of Co. I of the 28th IL Infantry was admitted to the Illinois Soldier's and Salor's Home; he was listed as Jeff Pence, a blacksmith in Barry in 1880 and also here in 1900; items in the Barry newspaper show he dabbled in other businesses, including operating a pool hall.

13328 JAMES PENCE was born in 1844 in Illinois.

1333 JEREMIAH PENCE was born 1 Jan 1807 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 27 May 1885 in Pike County, Illinois, buried Brawley-Iftner-Orr Cemetery, Pittsfield Twp, Pike County; married Margaret Brawley (also called Mary Ann and Mary Adaline) 26 Jan 1832 in Preble County, Ohio (she was born in 1811, died 16 Apr 1875 in Pike Couynty, buried with husband); to Pike County in 1837. Children include:

13331 NANCY JANE PENCE was born in 1835 in Ohio; married Alfred Wassell 8 Apr 1852 in Pike County, Illinois; also a Nancy J. who married William O'Brien 13 Nov 1866 in Pike County.

13332 LYDIA ANN PENCE was born in 1839 in Illinois; died 27 Jul 1894 in Portland, Multinomah County, Oregon; married James B. Orr 31 Aug 1854 in Pike County, Illinois (he was born 26 Sep 1833 in Harrison County, Ohio, died 28 Apr 1885 in Hannibal, Marion County, Missouri); they lived in Hannibal, Missouri, until his death and then she went to Oregon with a son, Frank Orr, in the late 1800s.

13333 MARY CAROLINE PENCE was born in 1841 in Illinois; married Ezra Masten 26 Jun 1856 in Pike County, Illinois.

1334 JOHN PENCE was born in 1806 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 5 Jul 1880 on a train in Missouri; married Hannah Earhart about 1829 (she was born about 1810, the daughter of George Earhart and Polly Marks); a John Pence, 74, was living with his daughter Mahala, age 30 (No. 13347), in 1880 with wife Hannah; also a John, 74, living with his daughter Jane, 35 (see Lydia J., No. 13346) in the same census, both Pike County, Illinois, probably the same person and enumerated twice; he was stricken on a train while he and his wife were on their way home from visiting a son in Kansas. From The Barry Adage, Barry, Pike County, Illinois, Friday, 9 Jul 1880 (apparently reprinted from a Missouri newspaper): "There was a sad and pathetic scene on a Missouri Pacific train last Monday night. An old man named John Pence and wife, of Barry, Illinois had been to Kansas to visit a son and on their way home, after the train had past Warrensburg [Johnsonn County, Missouri], the old man was taken quite ill, and Col. Crittenden and a couple of other gentlemen on the train went to his assistance and did what they could for him, but they soon saw that death was nigh. When Col. Crittenden informed the aged wife that her husband would soon die, she knelt down in the car and offered an eloquent and pathetic prayer, during which time the chains of death prevailed and there were no dry eyes. The old man, who was 77 years of age, died in about a half hour, and the remains were taken off at Sedalia [Pettis County, Missouri], placed in a coffin and passed through here Tuesday, enroute to Barry." Children:

13341 JEREMIAH PENCE was born 30 May 1830 in Butler County, Ohio (obit); died 21 Feb 1899 in Jefferson County, Kansas, buried Spring Grove Cemetery, Jefferson County; married Mary Ann Gleckler 24 Oct 1850 in Preble County, Ohio (she was born 8 May 1828 in Ohio, died 27 Sep 1901 in Jefferson County, buried Spring Grove Cemetery, the daughter of John Gleckler and Mary Magdalene Dilyard); obit says "he came to Preble County, Ohio, and there grew to manhood.... He removed to Illinois in 1854, to Missouri in 1865 and to Jefferson County in 1868. Children:

133413 JOHN WESLEY PENCE was born 18 Jan 1857 in Illinois; married (1) Gertrude Davis 14 Sep 1887 in Valley Falls, Jefferson County, Kansas, (2) Helena Elizabeth Underwood (aka Mrs. Lena Tharp) 16 Dec 1890 in Jefferson County; in Jefferson County in 1880 and 1900, and in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas, in 1920. Children:

1334131 LULA H. PENCE was born 2 Feb 1893 in Kansas (month and year from census, family says she was born in 1892); died - Nov. 1949 in Chicago, Cook County, Illinois; married James George Gray.

1334132 RUSSELL VERNON PENCE was born 30 Apr 1895 in Kansas; died 11 Jul 1969, possibly in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas (his Social Security address); married Ruth Shannon 23 Nov 1920 in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas (she died 3 Sep 1963); he registered for the World War I draft in Cochise County, Arizona.

1334133 WALTER MARLIN PENCE was born 23 Feb 1897 in Kansas; died - Apr 1960 in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas; married Lida _____ in 1922 (she was born in 1902 in Kansas); he registered for the World War I draft in Jefferson County, Kansas. Children in 1930 census of Topeka: RUTH E. PENCE (she was born in 1923 in Kansas), DALE L. PENCE (he was born in 1925 in Kansas) and ETHEL L. PENCE (she was born in 1927 in Kansas).

1334134 CLYDE PENCE was born in 1902 in Kansas.

1335 WILLIAM PENCE was born 24 Oct 1808 in Rockingham Co VA; died 29 Oct 1880 in Pike Co IL, buried Griggsville, Pike Co; married Sarah Stamback 31 Aug 1830 in Preble Co OH (she was born 3 Dec 1811 Rockingham Co, daughter of Frederick Stambach); they moved to IL in 1858. Children:

13352 MARY JANE PENCE was born 30 Jun 1833 in Preble County, Ohio; died 22 Feb 1908; married Elisha McChristy 17 Aug 1856 in Pike County, Illinois (he was born - Aug 1862 in Indiana); they were in Rosamond Twp, Christian County, Illinois, in 1900; the census for that year indicates she had given birth to seven children, six of whom were still living.

13352 MARY JANE PENCE was born 30 Jun 1833 in Preble Co OH; died 22 Feb 1908; married Elisha McChristy 17 Aug 1856 Pike Co IL.

13353 CATHERINE PENCE was born 5 Apr 1835 in Preble Co OH; married James Fife 28 Feb 1857 in Pike Co IL.

13354 JOSEPH PENCE was born 6 Jun 1837 in Preble Co OH; married (1) Emily J. (Emma) Jones about 1860, (2) Ann E. Hulse 25 Jan 1865 in Pike Co IL; but in Christian Co IL 1880 with wife Emily J., 1900 with Emily A. (possibly indicated that Ann E. was the same as Emily A.).

13355 WILLIAM PENCE was born 19 Sep 1839 in Preble Co OH; died 25 Sep 1892 in Pike Co IL, buried in Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Griggsville, Pike Co; married Sarah Little 9 Nov 1865 in Pike County; the lived in Pike Co in 1880.

13356 EMMA PENCE was born 19 Feb 1842 in Preble Co OH; died 9 Mar 1913; married (1) Joseph W. McElroy 16 Feb 1860 in Pike Co IL, (2) _____ McDevitt; to Christian Co IL.

13357 JULIA ANN PENCE was born 10 Jun 1844 in Preble Co OH; died 24 Dec 1914 in Spokane Co WA; married John Park Adams 28 Feb 1861 in Pike Co IL (he was born 9 Jul 1837 in Stephentown, Rensselaer Co NY, died 26 Sep 1921 at Orting, Pierce Co, WA, the son of Isaiah Adams and Amy Lester).

13358 SARAH JANE PENCE was born 19 Sep 1846 in Preble Co OH; died 12 Dec 1930 in Pike Co IL; married Joseph F. Fudge 22 Dec 1866 Pike Co.

13359 DAVID MILTON PENCE was born 1 Apr 1850 in Preble Co OH; died about 1918, buried Christian Co IL; married Rebecca Trainer about 1871; in Christian Co in 1880.

1335A HARVEY PENCE was born 22 Feb 1853 in Pike Co IL; died 13 Mar 1930, buried in Pike Co; married (1) Mary L. C. Reece 21 Feb 1875 Pike Co IL, (2) Martha Morris.

1338 ISAAC PENCE was born in 1816 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 18 Jan 1884 in Preble County, Ohio; married Mary Ann Swearer (Swain) 31 Dec 1840 Preble County. Children:

13381 FRANCIS PENCE was born - Mar 1842 in Ohio; married Eliza Jane Shaffer 21 Jun 1870 in Preble County, Ohio; they were in Preble County, Ohio, in 1880 and 1900; mother living with him in 1900.

13382 WILLIAM PENCE was born - Mar 1844 in Ohio; married Sarah A. Shaffer 18 Jan 1876 in Preble County, Ohio; they lived in Preble County in 1900.

13383 NATHAN PENCE was born in 1845 in Ohio; possibly died young.

13384 (MAHALA) JANE PENCE was born in 1847 in Ohio; died 8 Nov 1853 in Preble County, Ohio.

13385 SAMUEL PENCE was born - Dec 1846 in Ohio; married Margaret J. Wooten 6 Oct 1880 in Preble County, Ohio.

13386 MARTHA A. PENCE was born in 1852 in Ohio; possibly the "Mrs. Martha A. Pence who married Samuel L. McCoy 11 Mar 1875 in Preble County, Ohio.

13387 MARGARET (MAGGIE) PENCE was born in 1857 Ohio; married William Kirkpatrick 4 Jul 1880 in Preble County, Ohio.

135 HENRY PENCE was born 2 Dec 1785 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 14 Sep (1854?; tombstone illegible), age 70 years, 9 months, 7 days, Preble County, Ohio; married (1) Mary Harshman 12 Dec 1812 in Rockingham County (she was the daughter of Daniel Harshaman and Barbara Huffman), (2) Elizabeth Coppick 21 Apr 1844 in Preble County. Children:

1351 NIMROD PENCE was born 27 Nov 1813 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 15 Mar 1884 in Preble County, Ohio; married Elizabeth Kesling 21 Apr 1844 in Preble County (she was born 6 Mar 1822 in Preble County, died 4 Jun 1869 in Preble County, the daughter of Henry Kesling and Elizabeth Null).

1352 PHEBE ANN PENCE was born 27 Mar 1816 in Rockingham County, Virginia; married (1) Thomas J. Fudge 21 Mar 1839 in Preble County, Ohio (he was born 18 Jan 1815 and died in 1861, the son of David Fudge and Elizabeth Hunter), (2) Marion Swingley.

1353 ELIZABETH PENCE was born 29 Apr 1819 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 30 Apr 1821.

1354 LUCINDA PENCE was born 30 Jun 1821 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 11 Jun 1898 in Preble County, Ohio; married William Risinger 2 Apr 1844 in Preble County.

1355 DANIEL PENCE was born 2 Jan or 5 May 1824 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 1 May 1861 in Preble County, Ohio; married Catherine Fudge 1 Jan 1845 in Preble County (she was born 11 Sep 1824, died 18 Jan 1901, both Preble County).

1356 REBECCA (MARGARET) PENCE was born 4 Jun 1827 in Ohio; married Joseph J. Crane 29 May 1851 in Preble County, Ohio.

1357 RACHEL PENCE was born 12 Sep 1829 in Ohio; married Edwin R. Crane 29 Oct 1857 in Warren County, Ohio.

1358 JOHN PENCE was born 9 Jan 1833 in Preble County, Ohio; died 23 May 1895 at Catline, Parke County, Indiana; married Mary Agnes Gilpin 28 Oct 1855 in Preble County (she was born 1 Sep 1837 in Clinton County, Ohio, died 23 Jun 1925 at Catline, Parke County, Indiana, the daughter of Joseph Gilpin and Phebe Swearer; she was living in Racoon Twp, Parke County, in 1900.

1359 MARY ANN PENCE was born 6 Feb 1837 in Ohio; married Asa Riggs 25 May 1854 in Preble County, Ohio; to Parke County, Indiana.

137 JOHN PENCE (JOHANNES in birth record) was born 23 Feb 1791 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 9 Dec 1822 in Rockingham County, buried in Massanutten Cross Keys Cemetery, Cross Keys, Rockingham County; married Ann Kisling 29 Apr 1815 in Rockingham County (she was born 26 Feb 1792, died 10 Dec 1871, buried in Massanutten Cross Keys Cemetery); after John=s death she remarried to Rodham Kemper and had several more children by him); John, Ann and Rodham Kemper are buried in the same plot. Children:

1371 FRANKLIN KISLING PENCE was born 5 Jul 1816 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 8 Feb 1899; married Emily Caroline Gibbons 12 Sep 1846 in Rockingham County (she was born 18 Dec 1812 in Woodstock, Shenandoah County, Virginia, died 12 Oct 1883, the daughter of John Gibbons and Jane Elizabeth Keffer); they were in Floyd County, Georgia, in the 1880 census with no children living with them.

1372 MARY ANN PENCE was born 29 Jul 1818 in Rockingham County, Virginia; died 14 Feb 1846 in Rockingham County; married David Link 25 Oct 1843 in Rockingham County (son of David; he remarried).

1373 LUCY JANE PENCE was born 3 Apr 1821 in Rockingham County, Virginia; she was living in Rockingham with her mother Ann Kemper in 1860, unmarried.

139 PETER JONAS PENCE was born 11 Oct 1795 in Rockingham Co VA (church birth record, cemetery record says 10 Oct 1797); died 27 Aug 1864 Preble Co OH; married Elizabeth Harshman 13 Mar 1817 in Rockingham Co (she was the daughter of Daniel Harshaman and Barbara Huffman). Children:

1391 DELILAH PENCE born 13 Nov 1818 in Rockingham Cou VA; died 28 May 1868 in Defiance Co OH; married James Knox Pottorf 15 Oct 1840 in Preble Co OH (he was born 3 Jun 1817 in Preble Co, died 11 Mar 1889 in Defiance Co, son of Joseph Pottorf and Elizabeth Kesling).

1392 ROSABELLA PENCE was born in 1819 in Preble Co OH; married James H. Fudge 2 Nov 1838 in Preble Co (he was born 9 Dec 1812 in Warren Co OH, died 3 Jan 1865 in Preble Co).

1393 BARBARA PENCE was born 2 Oct 1820 in Preble Co OH; died 13 Apr 1901 in Preble Co; married Arthur Duffield 7 Sep 1847 in Preble Co.

1394 REUBEN KERCHEVAL PENCE was born 31 Mar 1822 in Butler Co OH; died 11 Nov 1909 in Morrisonville, Christian Co IL; married Margaret Louisa Watt 29 May 1848 in Preble Co OH; to Darke Co OH, then Christian Co in 1859.

1395 JOB PENCE was born - May 1824 in OH; died 4 Jun 1875 in Preble Co OH; married (1) Catherine L. Whiteneck 4 Mar 1855 in Preble Co, (2) widow _____ Sutton.

1396 SARAH JANE (SALLIE) PENCE was born in 1827 in Preble Co OH; married David Uriah Stebbins 26 Feb 1854 in Preble Co.

1398 ANDREW JACKSON PENCE was born 5 Dec 1833 in Preble Co OH; died 21 Feb 1909 in Preble Co; married Mary Jane Sherer 24 Aug 1856 in Preble Co (s